why is everyone laughing....am I missing something...edit oh I see... I think the color combo works better on black then it did white...I like this one...and all she was doing was giving a critique on a site that should be more open to them and not so stand offish to them
atomicchild said:why is everyone laughing....am I missing something...edit oh I see... I think the color combo works better on black then it did white...I like this one...and all she was doing was giving a critique on a site that should be more open to them and not so stand offish to them
Again, i disagree. There is critique, and there is being a know it all and trying to force your opinion down someones throat. Sure, she has great skills in some areas of art, but her critique on that shirt was incorrect to me, as well as many people.
She stated that "we didnt get it" although we did. We just disagreed with her stance, there is nothing wrong with that.
atomicchild said:Yes it is a critique....maybe could have been worded better.....but ultimately it is a critique
and here is the meaning
a criticism or critical comment on some problem, subject, etc.
so I would say her comment was a critique
Now you are just writing to argue man. I know what a critique is, Jimmy.
She is taking this whole "lets all critique every shirt ever posted like crazy" attitude to another level. Like i said, i disagree with her stance and i get that because you guys are all friends and hang out in tinychat all day you may favor her opinion more, but you also need to realize that it is ok to disagree with critique as well.
atomicchild said:Yes it is a critique....maybe could have been worded better.....but ultimately it is a critique
and here is the meaning
a criticism or critical comment on some problem, subject, etc.
so I would say her comment was a critique
Now you are just writing to argue man. I know what a critique is, Jimmy.
She is taking this whole "lets all critique every shirt ever posted like crazy" attitude to another level. Like i said, i disagree with her stance and i get that because you guys are all friends and hang out in tinychat all day you may favor her opinion more, but you also need to realize that it is ok to disagree with critique as well.
I am not trying to argue and I understand it is fine to have difference in opinion....I was just saying that it was a critique weather people liked it or not
This one actually looks a lot better! I see you are a little butt hurt and i'm not trying to critique things just for the sake of critiquing or making it all a personal opinion. And Daniel.. I am not critiquing every shirt ever posted, also..You didn't get it..I wasn't saying the shirt was terrible...I was saying the color in the end, that yellow was atrocious, it was dominating the photos, both the photos and the color were fighting for the spotlight. I just said it would look alot better dulled down a little, if the yellow was paler,or just not as intense. You guys I actually don't waste much time on extremely terrible stuff. I think this is a pretty balanced design, between the photos you used also the line and shape works very well. The yellow actually works very well on the black! Good job man.
congrats guys...somehow u guys have brought emptees back to life for a bit with all that useless arguing...lets focus on the design a bit more shall we.
27 Comments
DanielAndHisArt said about 1 year ago
Rules. Glad you got these approved. Stoked to pick them up. New record is jammin.
DESIGNByRDS said about 1 year ago
RobotTiger said about 1 year ago
DESIGNByRDS said about 1 year ago
gaunty said about 1 year ago
atomicchild said about 1 year ago
RobotTiger said about 1 year ago
Is that really a critique?
DanielAndHisArt said about 1 year ago
Again, i disagree. There is critique, and there is being a know it all and trying to force your opinion down someones throat. Sure, she has great skills in some areas of art, but her critique on that shirt was incorrect to me, as well as many people.
She stated that "we didnt get it" although we did. We just disagreed with her stance, there is nothing wrong with that.
atomicchild said about 1 year ago
and here is the meaning
a criticism or critical comment on some problem, subject, etc.
so I would say her comment was a critique
Cutty. said about 1 year ago
DanielAndHisArt said about 1 year ago
Now you are just writing to argue man. I know what a critique is, Jimmy.
She is taking this whole "lets all critique every shirt ever posted like crazy" attitude to another level. Like i said, i disagree with her stance and i get that because you guys are all friends and hang out in tinychat all day you may favor her opinion more, but you also need to realize that it is ok to disagree with critique as well.
atomicchild said about 1 year ago
I am not trying to argue and I understand it is fine to have difference in opinion....I was just saying that it was a critique weather people liked it or not
JeffByNight said about 1 year ago
TenTimesKarma said about 1 year ago
DESIGNByRDS said about 1 year ago
Victra said about 1 year ago
Jorge Gutierrez said about 1 year ago
DESIGNByRDS said about 1 year ago
Craig Robson said about 1 year ago
qetza said about 1 year ago
Paul Granese said about 1 year ago
chad manzo said about 1 year ago
and guys, chill out. just because we have different opinions doesn't mean we can't get along.;)
Victra said about 1 year ago
true that.
DCAY said about 1 year ago
Victor Mosquera said about 1 year ago