Champion Of Nothing said:Practising my illustration skills, some feedback would be rad!
what exactly are you using here, because I see no tapered lines at all? Like a mouse and photoshop?
I would suggest try more illustration traditional style first, pencil/pen and some paper life drawing. This guy here looks pretty insane, especially that mouth with those teeth. Are you going for a more realistic portrayal of a human face? Because the illustration is almost kind of funny like those meme faces.
Cheers for the feedback Killer Napkins (Huge admirer of your work), I used a tablet and illustrator for the line work and then took it onto photoshop for the colour. I do a lot of illustration by hand which usually is more textured and uses a wide range of mark making, however I'm struggling to re-create this digitally and therefore have converted to using colour, though I know I'm not 100% there yet. I think the reason it looks a bit like one of those meme faces is down to large areas of negative space, I really need to improve my digital mark making and my colour work (I normally work with a very limited colour pallet). Thanks again.
If you feel more comfortable illustrating by hand then I would say just do that and scan them in instead. Also you can set the sensitivity on the tablet to make the line width varied
I can't seem to get the scanned versions cleaned up , I don't know if that's because my scanner is poor or I trying to clean it up all wrong? I also use different brush widths on illustrator, though they aren't massively different I may try using a wider range of brush sizes in the future, thanks for the feedback!
On another note I love it anchored by land! (Especially the subtle distressing) Have you thought about half toning the picture in the background?
From a purely geometrical perspective, the triangle is a bit messed up. For one, the bottom of the triangle should not be pointed, but horizontal.
agreed. lets just take a look at this for a moment.
when you remove all the filler stuff and look at the actual drawing yu produced:
you've made some confident marks in this one but your clear lack of traditional mark making and compositional practice shows through in some areas. for example, if we take a look at the area where the antlers meet the ears, its not clear if the lines are describing the top of the ear or the underside of the antlers. its tricks the brain about and your eye doesnt pick out the ear as a positive shape, instead it looks like a hole instead. it starts to get confusing to view so your brain just dismisses it. try to make sure you dont put in any tricky tangents like that one in your drawings, it will help them read clearer and be more communicative.
the feathering technique you have used looks slightly forced and artificial, both due to the fact its a digital drawing but also because its not being used to describe anything (in the deer at least). the great thing about using that sort of halftone shading technique is that you can bend the shading to describe the form of a shape and it works really well.
i feel as though stylistically its sort of all over the place, its pandering to trends but without the confidence of understanding them. the beads hanging from the antlers would be a good touch if they felt congruent to piece, having them without a string or an outline and just floating like that makes them jar with the image.
everyone has said this before to you, try to take some time to study traditional mark making, form, lighting and composition before trying to carve out a style. it would show much more respect and effort if you posted a page of hand studies, a page of animal drawings, a sketch book of compositional studies etc.
From a purely geometrical perspective, the triangle is a bit messed up. For one, the bottom of the triangle should not be pointed, but horizontal.
agreed. lets just take a look at this for a moment.
when you remove all the filler stuff and look at the actual drawing yu produced:
you've made some confident marks in this one but your clear lack of traditional mark making and compositional practice shows through in some areas. for example, if we take a look at the area where the antlers meet the ears, its not clear if the lines are describing the top of the ear or the underside of the antlers. its tricks the brain about and your eye doesnt pick out the ear as a positive shape, instead it looks like a hole instead. it starts to get confusing to view so your brain just dismisses it. try to make sure you dont put in any tricky tangents like that one in your drawings, it will help them read clearer and be more communicative.
the feathering technique you have used looks slightly forced and artificial, both due to the fact its a digital drawing but also because its not being used to describe anything (in the deer at least). the great thing about using that sort of halftone shading technique is that you can bend the shading to describe the form of a shape and it works really well.
i feel as though stylistically its sort of all over the place, its pandering to trends but without the confidence of understanding them. the beads hanging from the antlers would be a good touch if they felt congruent to piece, having them without a string or an outline and just floating like that makes them jar with the image.
everyone has said this before to you, try to take some time to study traditional mark making, form, lighting and composition before trying to carve out a style. it would show much more respect and effort if you posted a page of hand studies, a page of animal drawings, a sketch book of compositional studies etc.
thnx for the crit man.this was originally a hand drawnpiece and i have actually fixed alote of things with it since i have posted it here, mainly the shape of the head and positioning of the horns and ears as i did find them awkward aswell..appreciate the feedback tho
284 Comments
cruise said about 1 year ago
DanielAndHisArt said about 1 year ago
that is freaking awesome dude. looking great.
cruise said about 1 year ago
Spill Your Gutts said about 1 year ago
Gyoza *drools*
Craig Robson said about 1 year ago
totally rules!
Stijn Van Belle said about 1 year ago
Super awesome dude, love this more than your usual work.
vad_ns said about 1 year ago
wip TDKR
vinbasshred said about 1 year ago
Infinite Black said about 1 year ago
Chreck said about 1 year ago
not exactly a sketch or illustration, but I'm doing a mural in Cabbagetown in Atlanta right now down the street with La Pandilla for Living Walls.
heat. said about 1 year ago
Ahah first idea that came to my mind, was something like this :)
Your linework is so good.
MattisGentle said about 1 year ago
I need to learn how to shade like this. I'm jealous :p haha
always amazing work man!
db said about 1 year ago
awesome!!
Victra said about 1 year ago
Brock May said about 1 year ago
Chreck said about 1 year ago
thank you thank you
parin said about 1 year ago
http://www.facebook.com/PCashmony
db said about 1 year ago
rad
Spill Your Gutts said about 1 year ago
This is just awesome.
I enjoy the mountains.
vad_ns said about 1 year ago
almost, maybe tomorrow
Champion Of Nothing said about 1 year ago
Killer Napkins said about 1 year ago
what exactly are you using here, because I see no tapered lines at all? Like a mouse and photoshop?
I would suggest try more illustration traditional style first, pencil/pen and some paper life drawing. This guy here looks pretty insane, especially that mouth with those teeth. Are you going for a more realistic portrayal of a human face? Because the illustration is almost kind of funny like those meme faces.
Champion Of Nothing said about 1 year ago
Andrew Haines said about 1 year ago
anchored by land said about 1 year ago
Joshua Jordan said about 1 year ago
From a purely geometrical perspective, the triangle is a bit messed up. For one, the bottom of the triangle should not be pointed, but horizontal.
anchored by land said about 1 year ago
Champion Of Nothing said about 1 year ago
On another note I love it anchored by land! (Especially the subtle distressing) Have you thought about half toning the picture in the background?
anchored by land said about 1 year ago
Champion Of Nothing said about 1 year ago
heat. said about 1 year ago
Chang your illo.
Brock May said about 1 year ago
DiegoMendez said about 1 year ago
keep practicing, champ
I finished this the other night
black and grey Faber Castell pens on toned paper. 18x22. ✌
Craig Robson said about 1 year ago
agreed. lets just take a look at this for a moment.
when you remove all the filler stuff and look at the actual drawing yu produced:
you've made some confident marks in this one but your clear lack of traditional mark making and compositional practice shows through in some areas.
for example, if we take a look at the area where the antlers meet the ears, its not clear if the lines are describing the top of the ear or the underside of the antlers. its tricks the brain about and your eye doesnt pick out the ear as a positive shape, instead it looks like a hole instead. it starts to get confusing to view so your brain just dismisses it. try to make sure you dont put in any tricky tangents like that one in your drawings, it will help them read clearer and be more communicative.
the feathering technique you have used looks slightly forced and artificial, both due to the fact its a digital drawing but also because its not being used to describe anything (in the deer at least). the great thing about using that sort of halftone shading technique is that you can bend the shading to describe the form of a shape and it works really well.
i feel as though stylistically its sort of all over the place, its pandering to trends but without the confidence of understanding them. the beads hanging from the antlers would be a good touch if they felt congruent to piece, having them without a string or an outline and just floating like that makes them jar with the image.
everyone has said this before to you, try to take some time to study traditional mark making, form, lighting and composition before trying to carve out a style. it would show much more respect and effort if you posted a page of hand studies, a page of animal drawings, a sketch book of compositional studies etc.
Andrew Haines said about 1 year ago
This is awesome
anchored by land said about 1 year ago
thnx for the crit man.this was originally a hand drawnpiece and i have actually fixed alote of things with it since i have posted it here, mainly the shape of the head and positioning of the horns and ears as i did find them awkward aswell..appreciate the feedback tho
jjworthington said about 1 year ago
boner jamz!!!
labyrinth said about 1 year ago
This is insane... I'm sure it'll turn out to be one of the selected designs. Can't wait to see the final product!
Decappuccino said about 1 year ago
Now that's what I'm talkin' 'bout.
cruise said about 1 year ago